Curmi & Partners

Beyond Market Volatility

Article by Maksym Skotarenko 

Recent turbulence across global financial markets has renewed attention on volatility and raised questions about the resilience of traditionally diversified investment portfolios. Following an extended period of strong equity market performance, the sharp correction in early November has prompted investors to reassess the sustainability of market valuations and the effectiveness of diversification across different asset classes.

On 5 November, the S&P 500 declined by 4.4%, while the tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite fell by 5.5%, entering correction territory as it dropped more than 10% below its October peak, according to Bloomberg data. Although the sell-off was particularly pronounced among semiconductor manufacturers and AI-related companies, weakness extended across the broader equity market, with all eleven S&P 500 sectors recording losses. Beyond the immediate market correction, these developments highlight the importance of understanding market concentration, changing correlations both within and across asset classes, and how different investments respond to periods of heightened uncertainty.

One interesting feature of recent market action has been the divergence between relatively subdued index volatility and substantial movements among individual securities. Research published by Société Générale in early November highlighted that implied equity volatility had remained relatively contained despite heightened geopolitical uncertainty, inflationary pressures and changing interest rate expectations. Over the preceding three months, the US VIX and European VSTOXX volatility indices averaged 16.3 and 17.7 respectively, broadly in line with their historical averages. However, under these headline measures, individual stocks and sectors were increasingly moving in different directions, with gains in some areas offsetting losses elsewhere and limiting overall index fluctuations.

According to Société Générale, approximately 40% of stock pairs among the 100 largest constituents of the S&P 500 exhibited negative three-month correlations, compared with around 30% within the Euro Stoxx 50. This reflects substantial divergence in the performance of individual stocks, with movements in opposite directions helping to contain volatility at the index level. While such divergence can provide diversification benefits, these relationships are not necessarily stable. If previously uncorrelated or negatively correlated stocks begin moving in the same direction, particularly during periods of heightened market stress, the offsetting effect weakens, potentially resulting in a sharp increase in overall index volatility.

Another important consideration is the increasing concentration of major equity indices, where a relatively small number of companies account for a substantial share of overall market capitalisation. According to Citadel Securities, the ten largest constituents of the S&P 500 represented approximately 37% of the index in early November. During the third quarter, these companies contributed 3.4 percentage points to the index's overall gain of 2.3%, while the remaining constituents collectively detracted from performance.

This concentration highlights how headline index returns can be disproportionately influenced by a handful of companies, potentially concealing weaker performance across the broader market. Consequently, even portfolios holding hundreds of individual securities may remain heavily exposed to the same companies, sectors and investment themes. During periods of market stress, shifts in investor sentiment towards these heavily weighted companies can therefore have a significant impact on overall index performance, underscoring the importance of assessing portfolio concentration rather than relying solely on the number of securities held in the portfolio for diversification purposes.

The implications become more complex when considering multi-asset portfolios, where diversification depends not only on the performance of individual investments but also on how different asset classes respond to changing economic conditions. Historically, government bonds have often provided protection during equity-market downturns. However, their effectiveness largely depends on the underlying cause of the correction. When equities decline amid expectations of weaker economic growth, government bond yields may fall as investors anticipate monetary easing, supporting bond prices. Similarly, during periods of heightened uncertainty, increased demand for safer assets can drive government bond yields lower, even without a significant deterioration in economic growth expectations.

The market sell-off on 5 November provides a recent illustration of the latter relationship. While the S&P 500 declined by 4.4%, the yield on the two-year US Treasury fell by approximately 12 basis points, while the ten-year yield declined by around 6 basis points, according to data published by the US Department of the Treasury. These movements illustrated how government bonds can provide diversification during periods of declining risk appetite, even when the initial equity-market weakness is not primarily driven by concerns over deteriorating economic growth.

Conversely, when market volatility is driven by persistent inflation or expectations of tighter monetary policy, government bond yields may rise alongside declining equity prices. Under such circumstances, the traditional diversification benefits between equities and government bonds can weaken considerably, potentially resulting in simultaneous losses across both asset classes.

Corporate bonds introduce an additional dimension, as their performance is influenced by movements in underlying government bond yields and changes in credit spreads. During periods of heightened uncertainty, widening credit spreads may offset the benefits of falling government yields, particularly among lower-rated issuers, whose performance is generally more sensitive to changes in economic conditions and investor risk appetite.

These contrasting relationships highlight why diversification cannot be assessed solely through historical correlations or the number of securities held. Investments that appear diversified across sectors, geographies and asset classes may nevertheless share exposure to common economic factors, including interest rates, inflation, economic growth and investor risk appetite. Furthermore, correlations observed during relatively stable market conditions may change significantly during periods of heightened uncertainty, potentially reducing the diversification benefits investors previously expected. For multi-asset investors, this reinforces the importance of monitoring portfolio concentration, understanding underlying risk exposures and assessing how different investments might perform under alternative economic scenarios.

Ultimately, recent market turbulence serves as a reminder that effective diversification is not simply about holding a broad range of investments, but about understanding how they interact. The key question is not how diversified a portfolio appears during stable market conditions, but whether that diversification remains effective when it is needed most.

Maksym Skotarenko is a Research Analyst and Portfolio Manager at Curmi & Partners Ltd.
The information presented in this commentary is solely provided for informational purposes and is not to be interpreted as investment advice, or to be used or considered as an offer or a solicitation to sell/buy or subscribe for any financial instruments, nor to constitute any advice or recommendation with respect to such financial instruments. Curmi & Partners Ltd, with registered address Finance House, Princess Elizabeth Street, Ta Xbiex, Malta XBX 1102, is a member of the Malta Stock Exchange and is licensed by the MFSA to conduct investment services business.

© 2016 Curmi & Partners Ltd. Proudly crafted by BRND WGN. Developed by Deloitte Digital.

Curmi & Partners Ltd is licensed to conduct investment services business by the MFSA under the Investment Services Act (Cap 370 of the laws of Malta) and is a Member of the Malta Stock Exchange.